Theo's Neighborhood Pizza, Covington

Nestled in the heart of Covington, Louisiana, Theo's Neighborhood Pizza offers a standout experience for pizza lovers seeking both quality and warmth. Specializing in thin-crust pizzas, this local gem boasts an inviting atmosphere where guests feel right at home from the moment they walk in.

The menu highlights are a true celebration of bold flavors and crave-worthy combinations. The Expert Pizza stands as a testament to their mastery—each bite delivering a perfect balance of savory toppings and a golden, crispy crust. For those who enjoy a smoky, tangy twist, the BBQ Chicken Pizza layers succulent chicken with a subtly sweet barbecue sauce, complemented by a touch of peppers that add just the right kick.

Theo's doesn't stop at pizza. Fresh side salad substitutions are available for a modest upcharge of $4.37, offering a crisp, refreshing contrast to the warm, cheesy mains. Don’t overlook the Chocolate Chip Cookie dessert, priced at $4.37, which rounds out your meal with gooey, home-baked sweetness that melts in your mouth.

To complement your meal, Theo’s thoughtfully curates a selection of domestic and specialty beers including favorites like Coors Light, Miller Lite, and the unique Louie Louie Blackberry Lemon THC Seltzer. This beverage lineup pairs beautifully with their bold pizza flavors, making each dining experience complete.

Many patrons have noted not just the food quality but the genuine hospitality that makes Theo’s stand apart. Matt C vividly recalls a late evening visit where the “amazing” pizza arrived timely, served in a warmly decorated space by staff that genuinely cared. Similarly, P N praised the friendly interactions, describing a personal touch where the staff not only offered a cold drink but also engaged warmly with customers, creating a welcoming, community feel. Karen Hanagriff highlights the team’s patience and precision during large group orders, noting perfection in every dish served and a “great value” in lunch specials.

While some guests find the counter-order system slightly unconventional, like Todd Bissel who prefers full table service for a leisurely night out, the overall consensus remains positive. The system allows for swift, no-fuss service, and the quality of pizza more than compensates for any minor quirks in service style. Kayla’s experience with the friendly staff and creative order visuals—using pictures instead of numbers—only adds to the unique charm of the place.

Theo’s Neighborhood Pizza isn’t just a place to grab a slice—it’s where authentic flavors meet genuine Southern hospitality. Whether you’re craving a perfectly crafted BBQ Chicken Pizza, a refreshing cold beer, or a cozy spot to catch up with friends and family, Theo's delivers a memorable dining experience that keeps locals returning time and again.